Issue Brief

What Did Pew Health Group Find in its Review of the U.S. Food Additive Regulatory Program?
 



In the November 1, 2011, edition of the peer-reviewed journal Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety (CRFS), Pew Health Group published a rigorous analysis of the U.S. food additive regulatory program. For this examination, Pew developed two novel methods to estimate the number of chemicals allowed in human food and the number of affirmative safety decisions for these substances. Key among the findings is that more than 10,000 chemicals were allowed in human food as of January 2011.

One-third of these chemicals (more than 3000) were approved by manufacturers or the Flavor and Extract Manufacturers Association (FEMA) Expert Panel. The remaining two-thirds were cleared by a federal agency—either the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) (in the case of pesticides) or the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) (for all other chemicals). Since many of FDA’s safety decisions covered multiple chemicals (sometimes hundreds of them), simply counting the number of chemicals overestimates the agency’s contribution. Therefore, the article includes a complementary method that suggests that manufacturers and a trade association may have made the majority of affirmative safety decisions.

. . .

Pew’s analysis found that the legal framework Congress created in 1958 has not kept pace with science and the food industry, essentially limiting FDA’s ability to effectively regulate chemicals added to food. The gaps in regulatory safeguards suggest that in many cases public safety is in the hands of the food manufacturers rather than FDA.

Four primary areas of concern were revealed through this analysis:

  • FDA is unaware of a large number of chemical uses in food and, therefore, cannot ensure that safety decisions regarding these uses were properly made.
  • Food manufacturers are not required to notify FDA of relevant health and safety studies, thereby placing FDA in the difficult position of tracking safety information for more than 10,000 chemicals with limited resources and information.
  • The agency’s expedited approach to reviewing safety decisions since 1995 occurs with little public engagement.
  • FDA lacks the resources and information needed to identify and prevent potential health problems or to set priorities for systematic reevaluation of safety decisions made during the past half-century.

Download the full PDF for more information.

Date added:
Jul 27, 2012

Related Resources

Delaware Online: Troubles at Serpe, Roos Invite FDA Scrutiny

Media Coverage
Repeated food safety problems at Elsmere's iconic Serpe & Sons Bakery and far worse health violations discovered at the shuttered Roos Foods cheese plant in Kenton are the latest examples of a dysfunctional national food inspection program, experts say.
More

Top Food Companies Moving Away From Overuse of Antibiotics on Industrial Farms

Consumers across the United States are demanding meat and poultry raised without antibiotics—and large producers, restaurants, and other institutions are listening. Following is a list of some leading companies offering responsibly produced food.

More

A Look Into Multistate Foodborne Outbreaks

Interactive
In January 2011, President Obama signed the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) into law, signaling the first major update to our nation’s food safety framework since the Great Depression. Despite bipartisan support, and a coalition of food safety advocates and industry representatives working for its enactment, the administration still has not issued the proposed rules needed to begin implementing this law. This interactive graphic represents the most widespread multistate foodborne illness outbreaks linked to FDA-regulated products since FSMA was enacted, which constitute a small fraction of total foodborne illnesses reported during that period. More

Multistate Foodborne Illness Outbreaks

Data Visualization

In January 2011, President Barack Obama signed the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) into law, signaling the first major update to our nation’s food safety oversight framework since the Great Depression. Despite widespread support for the legislation and its implementation, the Obama administration still has not issued all of the proposed rules under FSMA.

More

N.C. Family Faces Lasting Effects of Foodborne Illness

Other Resource
At age 3, Dana Dziadul of Wake Forest, NC, fell gravely ill after eating imported cantaloupe tainted with Salmonella. As her mom explains in this video, Dana continues to experience health consequences more than a decade later. More