Other Resource

Comments on USDA Proposed Standards for Snack Foods and Beverages Sold in Schools

The Kids’ Safe and Healthful Food Project (KSHF) is excited that more than 200,000 people all over the country submitted comments to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) encouraging strong nutrition requirements for all foods sold in schools, including snacks and beverages. Following is a summary of those KSHF submitted to USDA on the proposed rule.

For the first time in more than 30 years, USDA is updating nutrition standards for snack foods and beverages sold in schools. This proposed rule complements USDA’s standards for school meals, which took effect this school year.

Childhood obesity rates have more than tripled in the past three decades. Despite recent improvements to nutrition standards for school meals, the snack foods and beverages available to students are still largely less-healthy items like sugary drinks, salty snacks, and candy. It is time that ALL foods sold and served in schools are healthy for kids. This is a common-sense approach that strengthens the investment parents and taxpayers have made in our children and our schools.

Parents Want National Snack Standards

A 2012 poll found that 80 percent of parents support setting national standards for snack and a la carte foods and beverages. They are concerned about children’s health and want to make sure we are setting kids up for success.

These proposed guidelines have the potential to make a major difference. They would ensure that when kids make choices about snacks and drinks, the options they choose from are healthy ones – whether sold as a la carte items in the cafeteria, in vending machines, or in school stores. These items are a big part of what our young people eat — roughly 40 percent of students buy a snack at school every day.

Even if students eat a healthy lunch, research shows they often still consume excess calories from a la carte items the cafeteria might serve, such as french fries or ice cream. Sometimes kids skip a healthy meal entirely in favor of less-healthy snacks.

Strengthening the Smart School Snack Proposal

We commend USDA for proposing strong standards that will promote students’ consumption of healthy foods, such as fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and non-fat and low-fat dairy products, as well as limit calories, fat, sugar, and sodium in snack foods and beverages. These standards support what parents want and they support the recently updated standards for school meals.

There are certain areas of the rule that we recommend USDA consider strengthening, such as:

  • We urge USDA to ensure that all foods meet these standards, including items sold a la carte in the cafeteria, regardless of whether or not they’re sold in a regular school meal. Exceptions would create a loophole that will result in increased access to and consumption of less-healthy foods by students.
  • Similar to reimbursable meals, we advise USDA to implement calorie limits for snack foods and beverages that are tiered based on grade level. Calorie needs change as children grow. While 200 calories may be a reasonable limit for secondary school snacks, 200 calories is a significant portion of daily calorie needs for an elementary student. We propose:
  • 100 calories in elementary schools (grades K-5)
  • 140 calories in middle schools (grades 6-8)
  • 180 calories in high schools (grades 9-12)

Food companies are already making snacks that would fit these standards.

We agree with the rationale to offer some flexibility in beverage choices in high schools, but are concerned that sugary drinks are far less healthy than other options. To ensure the healthiest options are available, we recommend setting a limit for calories per container that is as low as possible.

Areas of Support

  • We agree that the rule should apply to all foods and beverages sold throughout the school day (until at least 30 minutes after school ends) and across the entire school campus. The same rules should apply inside and outside of the cafeteria throughout the day.
  • Foods sold in schools should meet strong standards for calories, fats, sugars, and salt, as well as provide students a positive nutritional benefit. This can be done by serving fruits, vegetables, whole grains, or foods that naturally contain meaningful amounts of a nutrient of public health concern (i.e., calcium, potassium, vitamin D, or dietary fiber).
  • We support allowing no more than 35 percent of foods’ calories to come from total sugars, as recommended by the Institute of Medicine.
  • The standards should be applied to foods and beverages as they are packaged and sold to children (i.e., one bag of chips should count as one serving).
  • Schools should make potable water readily accessible to children at no charge during the school lunch and breakfast meal service.

    For more information, see our detailed comments to USDA on the proposed Smart Snacks in Schools rule.
Date added:
Apr 15, 2013

Related Resources

Pew Commends Senators Collins and Heitkamp for Supporting Healthy School Foods

Other Resource
Jessica Donze Black, an expert with The Pew Charitable Trust’s initiative on child nutrition, issued the following statement on the School Food Modernization Act. More

States Need Updated School Kitchen Equipment

Other Resource
Eighty-six percent of schools in the United States are serving healthy lunches, but many could do so more effectively with updated equipment and infrastructure. Without the right tools, districts rely on workarounds that are expensive, inefficient, and unsustainable. Investing in kitchens and cafeterias could help schools better serve the nutritious foods and beverages that students need. More

National Nutrition Month Facts

Other Resource

March is National Nutrition Month, a time to focus new energy on giving kids healthy food options throughout the school day. Students consume up to half of their daily calories in school, so access to wholesome meals and snacks is important to their overall health. In fact, research shows that students living in states with strong nutrition laws gain less weight than those in states without such policies.


Education Week: Grants to Rehab School Kitchens Included in Obama's Budget Proposal

Media Coverage
About 88 percent of 3,459 food-service directors recently surveyed by Pew Charitable Trusts and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation said they needed additional equipment to adequately prepare meals. More

Bloomberg: Researchers On Free & Reduced Lunch, The Opportunity Gap

Media Coverage
Jessica Donze Black, director of the Pew Charitable Trusts’ Kids’ Safe and Healthful Foods Project, joins host Jane Stoddard Williams to discuss the National School Lunch Program that provides low-cost or free lunches to children. More

Civil Eats: State of the Tray: Will Recent Improvements in School Food be Rolled Back?

Media Coverage

Jessica Donze Black, director for the Pew Charitable Trusts’ Kids’ Safe and Healthful Foods Project, calls the modification change a “pragmatic and scientifically sound decision,” and San Francisco-based school food reformer Dana Woldow agrees: “[The calorie caps] will automatically limit the amount of potentially fatty protein and grains going into the meals. I think the days of seeing giant cheeseburgers the size of your head in school cafeterias may be over.”


NEAToday: Aging School Kitchens Undermine Healthy Meal Preparation

Media Coverage

It was food delivery day at Glen Landing Middle School in Blackwood, New Jersey, and the 42-year-old walk-in freezer went kaput. Again.


The State of School Nutrition

Other Resource
Kids consume up to 50 percent of their daily calories at school, so access to healthy meals and snacks is important to their overall health. This is especially true for the 21.5 million students who qualify for free or reduced-price meals and rely on food served in school to meet their nutritional needs. More

Serving Healthier Meals: California Schools Need Updated Kitchen Equipment

Other Resource
The majority of public schools in California are serving meals that meet updated, healthier nutrition standards. To do so, half of the state’s districts are cooking more meals from scratch. Scratch cooking can be challenging for schools—particularly those in older buildings—without the right kitchen tools for efficient preparation of healthy foods. More

Serving Healthy School Meals: Kitchen Tools Matter

How do you store extra servings of fruits and vegetables so schools can serve students the healthy foods they need to learn? Two school food service experts outline the importance of school kitchen equipment so that personnel have the right tool for the right job. More

Serving Healthy School Meals: Presentation Matters

Kids eat with their eyes, just like adults. Two school food service experts explain why presentation and equipment play important roles in getting kids to eat healthy foods. More

Serving Healthy School Meals: Kitchen Equipment

This is the second in a series of reports that summarizes how schools are putting in place updated U.S. Department of Agriculture, or USDA, meal standards and the challenges they must overcome to reach full implementation.


What Does a School Kitchen Need?

Data Visualization
Schools across the country are serving healthy meals, but many could do so more effectively with updated equipment and
infrastructure. More

Serving Healthy School Meals: Kitchen Equipment

Other Resource

Schools would be better able to serve healthy, appealing meals if investments were made in new kitchen equipment and infrastructure.


Report Finds That School Kitchens Need Significant Upgrades

Press Release

Only 1 in 10 school districts nationwide (12 percent) has all the kitchen equipment needed to serve healthy foods, according to a new report issued by the Kids’ Safe and Healthful Foods Project. The report makes recommendations for how schools, policymakers, industry, and philanthropic partners can work together to make these investments and provide healthy, appealing foods more efficiently. It is the first national assessment of districts’ kitchen equipment and infrastructure needs.