Other Resource

Pew Highlights Weaknesses in Poultry Safety System


New Report Offers Solutions to Better Protect Consumers From Foodborne Illness

 

Update: New Cases Identified in 2014

Between December 2013 and March 2014, more than 100 additional people were reported as having salmonella infections linked to chicken produced by Foster Farms, according to CDC data (updated 4/7/2014). 

This outbreak—the second traced back to Foster Farms chicken—began in March 2013 and has sickened at least 524 people in 25 states and Puerto Rico. The first outbreak (June 2012-April 2013) caused a reported 134 salmonella infections in 13 states.

The Pew Charitable Trusts released a report that examines how two recent outbreaks of foodborne salmonella infections exemplify flaws in the federal food safety program. The report, “Weaknesses in FSIS’s Salmonella Regulation,” also makes seven recommendations to improve the Food Safety and Inspection Service’s control of salmonella in poultry and strengthen its response to outbreaks caused by these bacteria.

“When more than 500 people get sick from two outbreaks associated with chicken that meets federal safety standards, it is clear that those standards are not effectively protecting public health,” said Sandra Eskin, director of Pew’s food safety project. “The Food Safety and Inspection Service should go beyond what it is proposing in its recently released ‘Salmonella Action Plan’ and do more to target salmonella, which is responsible for more hospitalizations and deaths than any other bacterium or virus.”

Among the report’s recommendations, FSIS—an agency within the U.S. Department of Agriculture—should:

  • Change its approach to developing and implementing limits on salmonella contamination for chicken, known as performance standards, so they are updated regularly, enforceable, and linked to public health outcomes.
  • Consider establishing limits on salmonella contamination for chickens when they enter the slaughterhouse.
  • Conduct unannounced salmonella testing in chicken processing facilities.
  • Communicate outbreaks to consumers via public health alerts as early as possible.
  • Close facilities under investigation for failing to produce safe food, and keep them closed until adequate control measures are in place.

In addition, the report recommends that Congress should grant FSIS the authority to mandate recalls.

chicken-store-300Background information:

  • According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, two multistate outbreaks of salmonella infections—the first lasted from June 2012 to April 2013, and the second started on March 2013 and is ongoing—were linked to chicken produced by Livingston, CA-based Foster Farms, the sixth- largest chicken producer in the United States. At least 658 people in 30 states and Puerto Rico were reported to public health authorities as having been sickened. Based on estimates by CDC, however, these outbreaks may have sickened as many as 19,000 people nationally owing to the underdiagnosis of salmonella.
  • It is estimated that salmonella causes more than 1 million foodborne illnesses every year.1 A recent review of scientific articles has identified several long-term consequences of salmonella infections, ranging from reactive arthritis to inflammatory bowel disease.2 The health-related costs of salmonella to the nation run as high as $11 billion a year.3 And about 90 percent of salmonella infections are foodborne, with contaminated poultry believed to be a primary cause.4
The Pew Charitable Trusts is a nonprofit organization that applies a rigorous, analytical approach to improve public policy, inform the public and stimulate civic life.  More information is available at www.pewhealth.org.

Related news


Endnotes

1Elaine Scallan, et al., “Foodborne illness acquired in the United States--major pathogens,” Emerging Infectious Diseases 17 (2011): 7-15. 
2Michael B. Batz, Evan Henke, Barbara Kowalcyk, editors David Acheson et al., “Long-term consequences of foodborne infections,” Clinics Review Articles, Infectious Disease Clinics of North America, Foodborne Illness: latest threats and emerging issues September 2013. 27 (2013) 599-616.
3Robert L. Scharff, “Economic burden from health losses due to foodborne illness in the United States,” Journal of Food Protection 75 (2012): 123-131.
4Shua J. Chai et al., “Salmonella enterica Serotype Enteritidis: Increasing Incidence of Domestically Acquired Infections,” Clinical Infectious Diseases 54(2012): S488-97.
Michael B. Batz, Sandra Hoffman, and J. Glenn Morris, “Ranking the Risks: The 10 Pathogen-Food Combinations with the Greatest Burden on Public Health,” 2011, accessed Oct. 17, 2013, olio.iupui.edu/bitstream/handle/10244/1022/72267report.pdf.

Date added:
Apr 18, 2014
Project:
Food Safety
Related Expert:
Sandra Eskin

Related Resources

Delaware Online: Troubles at Serpe, Roos Invite FDA Scrutiny

Media Coverage
Repeated food safety problems at Elsmere's iconic Serpe & Sons Bakery and far worse health violations discovered at the shuttered Roos Foods cheese plant in Kenton are the latest examples of a dysfunctional national food inspection program, experts say.
More

Reader's Digest: The Dangers in Our Food Supply Are Worse Than You Think

Media Coverage
All his life, Paul Schwarz had been active and healthy. When his family imagined the various ways that the decorated veteran of World War II might eventually die, they never imagined that the cause would be a piece of cantaloupe.
More

A Look Into Multistate Foodborne Outbreaks

Interactive
In January 2011, President Obama signed the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) into law, signaling the first major update to our nation’s food safety framework since the Great Depression. Despite bipartisan support, and a coalition of food safety advocates and industry representatives working for its enactment, the administration still has not issued the proposed rules needed to begin implementing this law. This interactive graphic represents the most widespread multistate foodborne illness outbreaks linked to FDA-regulated products since FSMA was enacted, which constitute a small fraction of total foodborne illnesses reported during that period. More

Multistate Foodborne Illness Outbreaks

Data Visualization

In January 2011, President Barack Obama signed the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) into law, signaling the first major update to our nation’s food safety oversight framework since the Great Depression. Despite widespread support for the legislation and its implementation, the Obama administration still has not issued all of the proposed rules under FSMA.

More

N.C. Family Faces Lasting Effects of Foodborne Illness

Other Resource
At age 3, Dana Dziadul of Wake Forest, NC, fell gravely ill after eating imported cantaloupe tainted with Salmonella. As her mom explains in this video, Dana continues to experience health consequences more than a decade later. More

Food Safety Advocates Share Their Views on Farm Bill

Opinion
As Congress and the President completed the farm bill in February, victims of foodborne illness and their families wrote letters to the editor applauding federal leaders for leaving out proposals that threatened to undo parts of the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act. More

Foodborne Illness Victims Go to Washington to Push for Safer Food

Image Gallery
On January 28-30, 2014, foodborne illness victims from 11 states visited Capitol Hill, asking their members of Congress to support the full funding and implementation of the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA). More

Raleigh News and Observer: Girl Fights to Save Others from Foodborne Illness

Media Coverage

Dana Dziadul has been fighting since she was 3 years old, but don’t bother telling her mother. First, Dana, now 16, was fighting for her life after getting debilitatingly ill from bad cantaloupe she ate when she was 3. Now, she’s fighting to ensure that other children don’t suffer the same fate that befell her – or a worse one.

More

WSB-TV: Parents Storm Capitol Hill for Safer Food

Media Coverage
Frustrated parents gathered on Capitol Hill demanding safer food Wednesday. Jacqueline Fell talked with parents who had to watch their kids get sick from food that may very well be sitting in your refrigerator right now. More

The Oregonian: Portland Cop Lobbying Congress for Food Safety Funding

Media Coverage
A Portland cop turned advocate is back in the U.S. capital this week, urging Congress to support funding for a crackdown on food safety. Officer Peter Hurley has met with two Oregon lawmakers, and has another meeting on Thursday. So far, the reaction has been mixed, Hurley said. More

New Mom Sickened by Listeria: 'Food Safety Affects Everyone'

Video
Merrill Behnke, of Bellevue, WA, was a healthy and proud new mom when a listeria infection caused by imported ricotta salata cheese put her in the hospital for 16 days. She describes the physical and emotional toll of her illness in this video. More

Victims of Foodborne Illness Tell Congress: Don't Forget Your Commitment to Make Our Food Safer

Other Resource

Victims of foodborne illness from 10 states are visiting Capitol Hill the week of January 27, asking their members of Congress to support the full funding and implementation of the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA). The advocates include children and adults who were sickened by foods they ate as well as sons and daughters who lost beloved parents to infections caused by contaminated products.

More

NBC News: How to Make Sure Your Chicken Is Safe

Media Coverage

Two respected consumer groups have issued reports criticizing the government’s failure to make sure the US poultry supply is safe. One group did a test of chicken bought in grocery stores across America and got unsettling results.

More

Oregonian: USDA Policies, Regulations Fell Short in Foster Farms Salmonella Outbreaks, Report Says

Media Coverage

A consumer group report released Thursday criticized the U.S Department of Agriculture's response to salmonella outbreaks traced to Foster Farms, saying the agency has not done enough to protect public health. The report by the Pew Charitable Trusts says federal regulations and policies are inadequate to prevent salmonella outbreaks stemming from chicken.

More

CNN: Report: USDA Should Do More to Fight Salmonella

Media Coverage

People infected with Salmonella develop diarrhea, a fever and abdominal cramps that usually last for four to seven days. The dangerous bacteria is found in the food we eat, usually chicken, beef or eggs that have been contaminated with animal feces. And a new report from Pew Charitable Trusts says the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) isn't doing enough to keep our food Salmonella-free.

More